MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Wisconsin Republican Eric Hovde refused to concede defeat on Tuesday to Democratic incumbent Tammy Baldwin in their U.S. Senate race, saying he was “deeply concerned†about the election results but that seeking a recount was a “serious†decision and he was still reviewing his options.
Hovde can request a recount because his margin of defeat was less than 1 percentage point, at about 29,000 votes. But he hasn't said yet whether he will request one, explaining in a video directed at his supporters that he wants to review all of the information and options that are available.
“This is a difficult decision because I want to honor your support and, at the same time, bring closure to this election for our state," Hovde said in the video posted on X.
Hovde pointed to what he claimed were irregularities with the vote results. There is no evidence of any wrongdoing in the election, the results of which are still being reviewed by counties before they submit the canvassed totals to the state by Nov. 19 for certification by Dec. 1.
Democrats, and even some Republicans, immediately called out Hovde for what they said was a perpetuation of lies about the integrity of the election.
“Stop trying to erode trust in our elections (and I say that as someone who supported Hovde),†said Jim Villa, a longtime Republican who previously worked in the Legislature and Milwaukee county executive's office under Scott Walker before Walker became governor.
“That grift needs to stop!†Villa posted on X.
Baldwin campaign spokesperson Andrew Mamo accused Hovde of “sowing doubt about our very democracy.â€
“Leaders on both sides of the aisle should condemn the lies he’s spreading and the pathetic campaign he continues to run,†Mamo said. “Tammy Baldwin has won this race and there is only one thing for Eric Hovde to do: concede.â€
John D. Johnson, a Marquette University researcher and data scientist, reacted to Hovde's video on X by saying, “Reckless disregard for the actual facts here."
Hovde also raised concerns about precincts in Milwaukee where turnout was higher than the number of registered voters posted on the county's website. That's because the original number posted didn't account for people who registered to vote on Election Day, something that happened in both Republican and Democratic parts of the state in the election.
The bipartisan Milwaukee Election Commission put out a statement refuting Hovde’s “baseless claims.†The commission said it was “fully confident that Mr. Hovde’s accusations lack any merit.â€
Andrew Iverson, executive director of the Wisconsin Republican Party, said that “Hovde has the right to request a recount and pursue legal remedies to address whatever concerns he may have regarding the election.â€
The Associated Press for Baldwin on Nov. 6 and on Thursday.
Although there is no evidence of wrongdoing in the election, many Hovde supporters have questioned a surge in votes for Baldwin that were reported by Milwaukee around 4:30 a.m. the morning after the election. Those votes put Baldwin over the top.
The votes were the tabulation of absentee ballots from Milwaukee. Those ballots are counted at a central location and reported all at once, often well after midnight on Election Day. Elections officials for years have made clear that those ballots are reported later than usual because of the sheer number that have to be counted and the fact that state law does not allow for processing them before polls open.
Republicans and Democrats alike, along with state and Milwaukee election leaders, warned in the days and weeks leading up to the election that the Milwaukee absentee ballots would be reported late and cause a huge influx of Democratic votes.
The reporting of those absentee ballots swung the 2020 presidential election to President Joe Biden, fueling baseless conspiracy theories that the election had been stolen from Donald Trump.
This year, the number of Democratic absentee votes in Milwaukee was not enough to sway the race for Vice President Kamala Harris, but it did put Baldwin over the top.
Hovde said before those ballots arrived that it “appeared†he had won and since last Wednesday, “numerous parties†had reached out to him about alleged inconsistencies.
But on election night, Republican strategists posted on X that Hovde was likely to fall behind Baldwin once the absentee votes from Milwaukee and other Democratic-heavy cities were posted. That is what happened.
Hovde would have to pay for a recount himself. The Wisconsin Republican Party has not been asked to pay for a recount, state party executive director Andrew Iverson said.
To seek a recount, Hovde would have to request one within three days after the last county completed its canvass of the vote. Those are due by Nov. 19, but counties could complete the task sooner.
Hovde, a multimillionaire bank owner and real estate developer, first ran for Senate in 2012 but lost in the Republican primary. He was backed by Trump this year and poured millions of dollars of his own money into his campaign.
